The Best Dinner Spot on Martha’s Vineyard: A Food Lover’s Guide.
Martha’s Vineyard isn’t just a paradise for beach lovers—it’s also a foodie’s dream, especially when the sun goes down. From upscale seafood restaurants to cozy farm-to-table bistros, the island offers incredible dining experiences. But where should you go for the absolute best dinner?
After savoring meals across the island, we’ve crowned the #1 dinner spot on Martha’s Vineyard—plus a few must-try alternatives.
🏆 The #1 Best Dinner Spot: The Beach Plum Inn & Restaurant (Menemsha)
Why It’s the Best
Perched above Menemsha Harbor, The Beach Plum Inn offers an unforgettable fine-dining experience with locally sourced seafood, elegant ambiance, and sunset views that are simply magical. The menu changes seasonally, but every dish is crafted with care, making it the top choice for a special night out.
Must-Try Dishes
✔ Pan-Seared Scallops – Perfectly caramelized, served with seasonal veggies.
✔ Grilled Swordfish – Fresh catch with citrus herb butter.
✔ Beach Plum Pavlova – A light, sweet finale with local berries.
Pro Tip: Book a table around sunset for the most breathtaking views!
🍽️ Runner-Up: State Road Restaurant (West Tisbury)
If you love farm-to-table dining, State Road Restaurant is a must. Their menu highlights Vineyard-grown produce, local meats, and creative New England flavors.
Top Picks:
✔ Wood-Grilled Oysters
✔ Braised Lamb Shank
✔ Buttermilk Panna Cotta
🍷 Best Waterfront Dining: The Lookout Tavern (Edgartown)
For a more casual (but still delicious) meal with harbor views, The Lookout Tavern serves up seafood classics and killer cocktails.
Don’t Miss:
✔ Lobster Roll (Connecticut-style, warm with butter)
✔ Clam Chowder (Award-winning!)
✔ Fish & Chips (Crispy and flaky)
🔥 Best Cozy & Romantic: Atria (Edgartown)
This chic, intimate spot in Edgartown is perfect for date night. Their dry-aged steaks and handmade pasta are legendary.
Signature Dishes:
✔ Dry-Aged Ribeye
✔ Lobster Fra Diavolo
✔ Dark Chocolate Soufflé
🍝 Best Casual & Fun: The Port Hunter (Edgartown)
A lively gastropub with craft cocktails and bold flavors, perfect for a fun night out.
Must-Order:
✔ Tuna Poke Bowl
✔ Braised Short Rib
✔ Bourbon Bread Pudding
Final Thoughts
While The Beach Plum Inn takes the crown for the best overall dinner experience, Martha’s Vineyard has something for every taste—whether you want fine dining, fresh seafood, or a laid-back pub meal.
What’s your favorite dinner spot on the island? Let us know in the comments!